The Twelve Centuries of Direct Captures Contest

Same here

Siganoff is out! Semifinals time!

Roshard M Whitehead, #1085, Ags 9, 2009
The last of 3 men who fled Operation Orange Tree. From 2004 to 2008, Whitehead's MO was to gain enough trust from parents to let him watch over their daughters, then show pornographic photos and videos to the girls, force them to act out what they saw, and threatened to beat and starve them if they didn't comply. After 3 airings and 2 months on the show, a tipster busted him hanging out with a 16 year old girl in Lexington, Kentucky. With his capture, all 80 targets of Operation Orange Tree were apprehended. A judge threw the book at Whitehead and sentenced him to 4 life terms.

vs

Darryl Crenshaw, #1055, Jnr 14, 2009
A serial abuser of girlfriends. In April 2008, he tried to kidnap one of his ex-girlfriends. In August 2008, he beat and strangled his last girlfriend Ashley Peoples in Connecticut... while out on bail! Somehow, Peoples' stepfather, a New England pastor, found the strength to forgive the judge and Crenshaw for her murder, leaving vengeance in the hands of the Lord. Less than one month after being named John Walsh's #2 most wanted fugitive of 2008, an AMW tipster busted him serving time in Mexico. During the extradition flight, tears welled up in his eyes, either out of remorse, or fear and defeat as he braced to face justice. He's since been sentenced to 78 years in prison.

and

Jeffrey Czechonna Miles and Anita Kay Vestal, #1066/#1067, Apl 19, 2009
In August 2008, Czechonna-Miles participated in a home robbery that ended in a shooting. The casualty toll was 2 dead, 1 wounded. After he was arrested, he befriended a prison guard named Anita Kay Vestal. In March 2009, Vestal supplied Czechonna-Miles with cell keys, set a diversion, and drove him off of prison grounds. They fled as far west as they could go, but within about a month, they were aired on an 8-second commercial break airing. A viewer busted them staying in a motel in Vallejo, California, and Czechonna-Miles is now serving life in prison.

vs

Michael Jason Registe, #1030, Ags 30, 2008
He first entered law enforcement's radar in November 2005 when he wounded a man who tried to buy his drugs. In July 2007, he murdered 2 of Georgia's Columbus State University's student athletes by shooting them execution style. 5 weeks after John Walsh named him the new guy on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted on the 7-26-008 FBI Centennial Special, an AMW tipster busted him in St. Maarten, in the Caribbean Sea. In May 2013, he pled guilty, and on top of having to negotiate an extradition warrant from St. Maarten, the death penalty was off the table. He was sentenced to 3 decades to life, with credit for time served.

Going to vote the same as Scumhunter on this one, although all four cases were excellent captures.

I agree with you Since Crenshaw was given a full profile and Registe was given a short profile

This is really tough but I vote for Crenshaw because his potential for re-offense and becoming a possible serial rapist or killer was extremely high. (We didn't know at the time he was in Mexico in poor shape).

I'm actually voting for Michael Registe for being wanted for a higher casualty count, as well as being the last FBI Ten Most Wanted fugitive caught by AMW.